Jaideep Hardikar's article, 'One suicide every 8 hours', has some excellent facts and figures but there's one dot Hardikar fails to connect.
Hardikar tells us:
*Farmer suicides have been escalating in the Indian cotton growing area of Vidarbha at an extraordinary rate, with more than 40% of the farmer suicides of the last 5 years occurring in roughly the last 12 months.
*Cotton farmers are affected more than any other group of farmers.
*The area under Bt cotton has risen from a mere 0.4% in 2002-03 to 15% in 2005-06 in Vidarbha
The fact the article fails to tell us:
*Although even now Bt cotton production accounts for only 15% of the area cultivated, the majority of the cotton farmers taking their lives have been Bt cotton growers.
This is hardly surprising given that input costs are recognised as being a critical factor in exacerbating the debt burden that's driving the suicides. Bt cotton seed is very expensive, costing 3 times mores than non-Bt cotton seed.
As even GM-enthusiast MS Swaminathan has recognised, "In Vidharbha, it is too risky to adopt expensive technologies. Small farmers who take loans for cultivation have no capacity to meet the calamity of crop failure."
MS Swaminathan to his credit goes on to say, "organic farming and crop-livestock integration should be promoted on both ecological and economic grounds."
For more on the problems of GM cotton and how a series of studies show that it does not make economic sense for small farmers:
'New studies highlight the failures of GM cotton - podcast and transcript' http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=6904
One suicide every 8 hours
Daily News & Analysis (India), August 26, 2006 http://www.dnaindia.com/report.asp?NewsID=1049554
Vidarbha remains a grim statistic. One suicide in every eight hours. More than half of those who committed suicide were between 20 and 45, their most productive years. The Maharashtra government says as many as 1920 farmers committed suicide between January 1, 2001 and August 19, 2006. Nearly 2.8 million of the 3.2 million cotton farmers are defaulters, reports Jaideep Hardikar
There are no authentic figures on the exact number of farm suicides in Vidarbha, but the Maharashtra government accepts a figure of 1920 from January 1, 2001 to August 19, 2006. The Vidarbha Jan Andolan Samiti (VJAS), a farmers' movement, puts the toll at 782 from June 1, 2005 to August 26, 2006. And, in the last three months, there has been a suicide every eight hours.
Cost of cultivation
Across the country, the average cost of cultivation in cotton is a little more than Rs 16,000 per ha. With an average productivity of 460 kg per ha, it costs between Rs 35 to Rs 48 per kg to grow cotton. In Vidarbha, the cost of cultivation could go well beyond Rs 20,000 perha and if marketing cost is added, it crosses Rs 22,000. But the productivity is only 146 kg per ha. In other words, the cost per kg is almost double --- well over Rs 70 per kg. In Maharashtra, the cost of growing cotton increased from Rs 17,234/ha in 2001-02 to Rs 20,859 in 2002-03.
Right age, wrong step
Among the farmers who committed suicide in the past year, more than 50% were between 20 and 45 years of age (their most productive years), according to a study by the Sakal Newspapers Limited of the two districts, Amravati and Yavatmal.
The hybrid cotton covers about 73% of the cotton area in Vidarbha, whereas desi varieties cover about 27%. Most of these produce medium to medium-long fibre.
Area under Bt cotton has risen from a mere 0.4% in 2002-03 to 15% in 2005-06 in Vidarbha, according to the agriculture department statistics. Only 3% cotton land falls under assured irrigation. Cotton area has declined from 16.12 lakh ha in 2001 to 12.18 lakh ha in 2005-6. Only 3% of it is under irrigation. The shift is towards soybean.
The Planning Commission's fact-finding mission members found out that nearly 2.8 million of the 3.2 million cotton farmers in Vidarbha are defaulters. Of every Rs 100 borrowed, approximately Rs 80 goes back in to servicing of old loans.
The Prime Minister in his Rs 3750-crore package jacked up an additional credit flow of Rs 1200 crore taking it to Rs 2000 crore for 2006-07. But the ground situation shows a credit disbursal of less than a thousand crore.
Is there light at the end of the tunnel?
Revive traditional crops. Pump money back into the rural economy, say experts
"In Vidharbha, it is too risky to adopt expensive technologies. Small farmers who take loans for cultivation have no capacity to meet the calamity of crop failure. Traditional crops like jowar should again be revived. The funds allotted under the Prime Minister's package for seed replacement should be used to promote jowar, pulses and legumes. Also, organic farming and crop-livestock integration should be promoted on both ecological and economic grounds. Vidharbha can be declared as the Organic Farming Zone of Maharashtra, so that its oranges, jowar, cotton and other crops become known as organic products and thereby gain in market value." - MS Swaminathan Chairman, National Commission on Farmers
"It's not true that suicides are taking place only in Vidarbha. They began in Andhra and spread to other parts of the country. But why did farmer suicides begin after 1994? The answer is we liberalised the economy and devalued our rupee. As a result, the cost of energy went up, the cost of agriculture rose and living costs soared. The 5th Pay Commission was a vindication of this. But the farmers remained in a low-cost economy. The promise that exports in a free market would bring profits to farmers was never kept. We imported 110 lakh bales from 1998 to 2004." - Vijay Jawandhia Wardha farmers leader, social commentator
"The point is we need to understand th
Go to a Print friendly Page
Email this Article to a Friend
Back to the Archive