The food industry piece below describes research showing how maize containing high concentrations of beta-carotene when fed to gerbils increased their vitamin A status, suggesting it could be used to tackle vitamin A deficiency in humans.
The article went out yesterday on CS Prakash's pro-GM listserv AgBioView along with a piece about Golden Rice. The context, combined with a certain lack of clarity in the article itself, will almost certainly have lead readers to conclude that here at last was a GM crop that could deliver.
But when we asked the lead researcher, Juliet Howe, whether the maize was GM, Dr Howe told us, "The biofortified maize used in the study was bred using traditional breeding practices. It is not transgenic."
So we have yet another non-GM success story being presented as if it supports the value of GM crops, when it really indicates how unnecessary they are.
This follows the success of scientists working at the International Rice Research Institute in breeding by conventional means a rice variety that contains much higher than usual levels of iron along with Vitamin A and zinc. ("Dream rice to curb malnutrition")
Beta-carotene-rich maize boosts vitamin A in rodents
By Stephen Daniells http://www.foodproductiondaily.com/news/ng.asp?n=70826-syngenta-beta-carotene-vitamin-a-deficiency-biofortication
26/09/2006 - Maize, bred to contain high concentrations of the pro-vitamin A carotenoid, beta-carotene, did increase the vitamin A status in gerbils, and could be used to tackle vitamin A deficiency, says a new study.
"In populations consuming maize as a staple food, using orange instead of white maize could dramatically affect vitamin A status," wrote authors Julie Howe and Sherry Tanumihardjo from the University of Wisconsin.
Vitamin A deficiency (VAD) is a public health problem in more than 50 per cent of all countries, especially in Africa and South-East Asia, according to the World Health Organisation, and causes blindness in up to 500,000 children each year. The human body converts beta-carotene in the diet into vitamin A.
Research into biofortication of plants continues to explore ways of increasing the vitamin A status and is being strongly supported by several humanitarian agencies like Harvest Plus, which is actively funding biofortified crop breeding in developing countries.
Syngenta has been highly active in producing transgenic beta-carotene-rich rice, and announced in 2005 a new GM rice, called Syngenta Golden Rice II, that produces up to 23-times more provitamin A nutrients than the original beta-carotene-rich Golden Rice. This gives the rice a maximum carotenoid level of 37 micrograms per gram of rice and a preferential accumulation of beta-carotene.
However, Greenpeace have been very vocal in criticising the lack of information given on the bioavailability of beta-carotene from the rice in the body, noting that the original variety was also designed to increase intake of this nutrient but children could not get their daily requirement from eating normal quantities of rice.
Similar questions remained regarding the bioavailability of carotenoids from biofortified maize, said Howe and Tanumihardjo, despite efforts to produce biofortified maize with provitamin A carotenoids being successful. They set about testing whether feeding beta-carotene-rich maize to vitamin A deficient Mongolian gerbils would improve the vitamin A status of the rodents.
Forty gerbils were fed a standard diet of white maize (low beta-carotene content) for four weeks before starting the experiments. The gerbils were divided into four equal groups and fed an oil control, 60 per cent high-beta-carotene maize, and beta-carotene or vitamin A supplements (matched to high-beta-carotene maize) for four weeks.
The authors, writing in the October issue of the Journal of Nutrition (Vol. 136, pp. 2562-2567), report that concentrations of vitamin A in the liver of the gerbils eating the high-beta-carotene maize group was 150 per cent that of the control group (0.25 versus 0.10 micromoles/gram, respectively), and equalled that of the group receiving the beta-carotene supplements. The vitamin A supplemented group had higher liver concentrations of the vitamin than the other groups (0.56 micromoles/g).
It was found that bioconversion of the beta-carotene to retinol (vitamin A) was about three micrograms of beta-carotene to one microgram of retinol (1.5 mol beta-carotene to 1 mol retinol).
The concentrations of beta-carotene in the livers of the gerbils eating the high-beta-carotene maize was almost double that of the beta-carotene supplement group (26.4 versus 14.1 nanomoles, respectively).
"Biofortified maize adequately maintained vitamin A status in Mongolian gerbils and was as efficacious as beta-carotene supplementation," concluded the researchers.
If such studies can be further reproduced in additional animal studies, and subsequently in randomized control trials with humans, the crops may offer a vital route for reducing the burden of vitamin A deficiency.
A number of genetically modified plants and crops are coming to light with enhanced nutritional content considered to offer human health benefits, including zeaxanthin to potato tubers, and the omega-3 fatty acid, eicosapentaeoic acid (EPA), to soybeans and brassica, and stearidonic acid (SDA) in canola crops.
However, no GM crops with potentially enhanced health benefits have been approved for human consumption, and consumer acceptance, particularly in Europe, and most notably in the UK, continues to be one of the biggest challenges for these crops.
Go to a Print friendly Page
Email this Article to a Friend
Back to the Archive