GM WATCH COMMENT: When the State Government in Tamil Nadu claims it is "too early to be concerned" about GM rice trials, it entirely misses the point.

It may easily already be too late. The US rice industry faces its gravest crisis ever thanks to GM rice trials that finished 5 years ago. Now it's facing an export melt down in some parts of the world and a mess of litigation.

And the State Government's claims that the trials in India are transparent etc. are laughable. They've been secretive and shambolic with multiple biosafety violations. And don't forget that those who ran the GM rice trials in the US say they not only followed the biosafety guidlines but exceeded them, and they still plunged the US rice industry into its present disaster.

Finally, the parallel that the State Government tries to draw with Bt cotton is also invalid. For one thing, not only do problems with Bt cotton persist, they're getting worse - see, for instance, 'Bt cotton bubble set to burst: Experts'
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7275

Most farmer suicides relate to GM cotton
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7087

And the parallel's also invalid because there has never been an effective consumer boycott of GM cotton, whereas GM food crops are another matter entirely - witness the collapse of US rice exports to Europe, Japan, etc.

Does India really want to kiss goodbye to its Basmati exports? India's rice exporters and farmer organisations like the BKU and others have said that would be a disaster.

The only problem is the corrupt and complacent governing elite who appear not to give a damn about farmer suicides or lost markets.
---

Government has 'open mind' on GE crops issue: Minister
Vani Doraisamy
The Hindu,
http://www.hindu.com/2006/11/17/stories/2006111714920600.htm

*It is too early to be concerned about this, says Veerapandi Arumugam
*State follows protocol set by Union Environment Ministry
*Farmers threaten mass movement against the crops

CHENNAI:

With farmers all over the State threatening a "war unto the finish" against genetically engineered crops, the State Government on Thursday said it had an "open mind" on the issue and would allow the crops only if they were proved to have no demonstrable side effects.

"The company [Monsanto-Mahyco] approached us with a request to test the crops. The trial is only in the research phase now and the results will be sent to the Indian Council of Agricultural Research and, later, the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee, to decide if the crops are harmful to farmers or not. We will go by whatever the committee decides. If the council gives a negative report, we will not allow cultivation in the State," Agriculture Minister Veerapandi Arumugam told The Hindu.

Pointing out that earlier, when BT cotton made its entry into the State, farmers had the same apprehensions which the then government had allayed, Mr. Arumugam said the Government was keen on ensuring that the GE crops would not pose any threat to traditional crop varieties. "We are open to talk with farmers' associations. It is too early to be concerned about this."

"The State follows the protocol [on GE crop cultivation] set by the Union Ministry of Environment. While farmers can bring protocol violations to the notice of authorities, we cannot block such transfers of technology. The trials have been done in a transparent manner and the State cannot intensively promote agriculture through prevalent technologies alone without updating them," a top government official said.

On warpath

Farmers' representatives, however, are unwilling to buy the argument and insist they will take the warpath if trials are allowed to continue. "The issue of whether GE crops can be allowed in the State cannot be decided by officials or scientists alone, without taking farmers' livelihoods into account. We do not oppose technology per se as we have already adapted to the cultivation of hybrid crops strains. GE crops, however, will land us in a vicious circle of debt and penury, as seen in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh. We will try to impress upon the Government the urgency of the situation, failing which we will launch a mass movement against the crops," said V. Durai Manickam, general secretary, Tamil Nadu Farmers' Association.

Go to a Print friendly Page

Email this Article to a Friend

Back to the Archive