WEEKLY WATCH number 150 (10/11/2005)

from Claire Robinson, WEEKLY WATCH editor
------------------------------------------------------------

Dear all:

Anyone struck by the contrast between the absence of appropriate precaution displayed by so many British and American politicians over pollution, global warming and emergency planning for 'natural' disasters, and the excess of precaution the same people display over bird flu, should read our section, POLITICANS MAKE MONEY FROM DISEASE SCARES.

And there's great news about the Polish farmer who faced prison for protesting against GMOs (EUROPE). And South Africa looks set to turn its back on the GM cattle drug rBST, under pressure from its milk suppliers (AFRICA).

Claire [email protected]
www.gmwatch.org / www.lobbywatch.org

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONTENTS
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUSTRALASIA
ASIA
EUROPE
THE AMERICAS
AFRICA
POLITICANS MAKE MONEY FROM DISEASE SCARES
BIOTECH MEDICINES
BIOFUELS
INDUSTRY NEWS
EPIGENETICS
GM TREES

------------------------------------------------------------
AUSTRALASIA
------------------------------------------------------------

+ OZ FARM GROUPS IN BED WITH GM LOBBYISTS
The leading lights of a Western Australian farmers' group (WAFarmers) brag in a recent press release about how they have been "lobbied by the major players in GM technology" and then repeat the claims of those lobbyists as if they were matters of fact. These include a claim that "the current moratorium is standing in the way of progress".

This is combined with a call for Western Australia's Agriculture Minister to stop "politicising" the GM issue, and to stop "working in isolation within the comfort zone provided by the [GM] moratorium", and to embrace instead "the wealth of knowledge available through industry expertise"!

It's not every day that a government minister is baldly advised to give up his political judgement in favour of heavily-lobbied industry advice! But such a corrupt proposition apparently makes perfect sense to the President and the Communications Officer of WAFarmers.

Meanwhile, an ex-Monsanto manager for GM crops in Australia publicly boasts about how he has helped to "evolve" the policies of "the Gene Technology Grains Committee, Australian Seeds Federation, Australian Oilseeds Federation and more recently Ausbiotech, and the Grains Council of Australia."

In short, it seems to be GM industry lobbyists who shape the policies of the bodies that supposedly represent Australia's farmers.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=5919

+ OZ INDUSTRY LEADERS BETRAYING FARMERS
The Network of Concerned Farmers (NCF) is warning industry leaders that they should not ignore the economic wellbeing of farmers in their personal support of GM crops. The NCF claim industry leaders are betraying farmers to side with the GM companies.

"We are being sold out by our industry leaders and they should be held accountable for accepting liability on behalf of farmers," said Juliet McFarlane, canola grower from Young, NSW.

"Why are existing policies being ignored? Why are ex-Monsanto managers and GM companies now actively working with farm lobby groups to evolve policies and strategies? ... The GM industry must be laughing at our industry leaders. The GM benefits are just not there to pay for the multitudes of parasites wanting to profit from GM introduction."

The NCF claim that State lobby groups such as NSW Farmers, WA Farmers, GRDC, AWB and GCA are making statements that clearly oppose the policies and constitutions of their own organisations.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=5924

------------------------------------------------------------
ASIA
------------------------------------------------------------

+ NEW REPORT ON BT COTTON PROBLEMS IN ANDHRA PRADESH
Recently we circulated a report on the problems with Bt cotton in the central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh. Now we have another important report on some of the severe problems being found in Andhra Pradesh. This report comes from a Fact Finding Team which visited Adilabad district and which included eminent agriculture scientist and Advisor to the Andhra Pradesh Government, Dr K R Chowdhary.

EXCERPTS FROM THE NEW REPORT:
In the case of those farmers who had sown Bunny Bt Cotton, the seed did not germinate properly...

Other Bt-cotton fields are severely infested with the sucking pest complex - jassids, aphids and thrips...the boll size, number of bolls and cotton weight in Bt-hybrids is less compared to non-Bt Cotton hybrids...

Bt Cotton is severely affected by leaf curl and reddening of leaf was found as a result of both damage by jassids and leaf curl of TSV [Tobacco Streak Virus] transmitted by thrips [the incidence of TSV on Bt cotton has been confirmed by various agencies...]

...[very close] non-Bt cotton fields are affected by these pests and diseases to a very low degree.

The overall growth of the Bt-crop was stunted... However, other non-Bt hybrid crops in the vicinity have grown above three feet... Farmers say they can expect a good crop from non-Bt fields.

Read the report in full.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=5918

+ PUSZTAI IN DELHI
Dr Arpad Pusztai has been in Delhi speaking about the lack of evidence that GM foods are safe for human health or the environment. On the health safety aspect, he said that so far only 19 peer-reviewed papers have been published. Only one human clinical trial has been conducted and only a few animal studies done so far. Dr Pusztai alleged that the industry's and regulator's preferred "safety assessments" are based on the poorly defined and not legally binding concept of "substantial equivalence."

"In such a situation it is difficult to conclude that GM foods are safe," he told an audience that was described in the Financial Express as "spell-bound".

Print

Back to the Archive