WEEKLY WATCH number 200 (18/11/2006)

from Claire Robinson, WEEKLY WATCH editor
------------------------------------------------------------

Dear all:

The 200th edition of Weekly Watch is bursting with news and information from right around the world.

Amongst much else, watch out for a very important article from the Indian press - 'BT BUBBLE SET TO BURST - EXPERTS' - warning that pest resistance to GM cotton in Gujarat is making the technology redundant. "As for the rest of the country, it's only a question of time," says Dr K R Kranthi, a GM supporting scientist at the Central Institute of Cotton Research. This latest setback for the industry comes as opposition to GM is spreading like wildfire in India (ASIA).

Finally, for some extraordinary insights into the corporate character of Bayer and Monsanto, see CORPORATE CRIMES.

Claire [email protected]
www.gmwatch.org / www.lobbywatch.org

------------------------------------------------------------
CONTENTS
------------------------------------------------------------

GM RICE CONTAMINATION
ASIA
LOBBYWATCH
AUSTRALASIA
AFRICA
THE AMERICAS
CORPORATE CRIMES
EUROPE
RESEARCH
GM TREES

------------------------------------------------------------
GM RICE CONTAMINATION
- THE INDUSTRY'S WORST EVER CRISIS
------------------------------------------------------------

An article from the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, "Rice farmers biggest losers over altered rice, exec says", gives a graphic and revealing picture of just what GM contamination has meant for US farmers, millers and exporters.

It's a picture that should set alarm bells ringing worldwide whenever GM crop trials are proposed.

Remember: no GM rice has ever been grown commercially in the US. There were only ever trials, and those trials were completed five years ago - back in 2001.

So what has the GM contamination discovered some five years later meant for the US rice industry?

*The industry's worst ever crisis

*41% of US rice exports negatively affected
*More than 25 federal lawsuits filed
*Trade with the 25-nation EU at a standstill
*Other countries have banned US long-grain rice imports
*Many other countries requiring testing
*Some markets for medium- and short-grain rice also affected
*The problem involves not just Bayer's (GM) LL601 rice
*Another Bayer GM rice, LL62 has been detected in Europe and in US testing *32% of nearly 700 long-grain rice samples - including everything from unmilled to parboiled rice - tested positive for GM traits
*GM traits are so prevalent that "you cannot guarantee statistically that you'll ever get rid of them"
*US rice can never again be validly described as "GM-free".

As if all that weren't bad enough, another big headache for US rice farmers, as they struggle to eliminate GM contamination in order to try and regain market share in the future, is the lack of any certainty about the source of the problem.

In August this year, a sample of Cheniere foundation seed grown in 2003 was found to contain a trace amount of LL601. Cheniere is the only seed rice that has tested positive for LL601. However, in the US's biggest rice growing state of Arkansas only 11-12% of all the rice acres were planted in Cheniere while 31% of Arkansas rice has been testing positive.

In other words, three times more rice has been contaminated than one would predict if the Cheniere variety was the sole source of the contamination.

And although Bayer is widely blamed for the multiple problems and the massive losses, so far the company has not stumped up a cent.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7271

------------------------------------------------------------
ASIA
------------------------------------------------------------

+ BT BUBBLE SET TO BURST - EXPERTS
A very important article in the Deccan Herald quotes pro-GM Indian scientists as warning that bollworm resistance to Bt cotton is growing in Gujarat, making the technology redundant. "Pockets near Vadodara are the cause of immediate concern. As for the rest of the country, it's only a question of time," said Dr K R Kranthi from the Nagpur-based Central Institute of Cotton Research.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7275

+ TERMINATOR IN INDIA: TRIALS MAY HIT ROADBLOCK
India's Financial Express reports that Delhi University's GM mustard field trials may face difficult times ahead. Aruna Rodrigues has drawn the attention of India's Supreme Court to the suspected application of genetic use restriction technologies (GURTs) in the development of the crop.

The paper says that GURTs, known as terminator technology, produces terminator seeds which do not germinate when saved for the next crop season. India's Plant Varieties Protection & Farmers' Rights Act banned the use of such seeds in India.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7262

+ ANOTHER GM RICE TRIAL DESTROYED IN INDIA
Over 200 farmers, under the banner of the Tamil Nadu Farmers' Association, destroyed a GM Bt rice field trial in a village about 20 km from Coimbatore. Monsanto-Mahyco appears to have been carrying out the Bt rice trial without even telling the farmer it was GM.
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7258
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7259
http://www.lobbywatch.org/archive2.asp?arcid=7280

Suman Sahai writes in the Times of


Print

Back to the Archive