CS Prakash of AgBioWorld fame topped one of his recent AgbioView bulletins with the following message:
Note from Prakash:
Due to overwhelming hits received on our website because of the WTO ruling, our server went mad, was dead for a while, angrily spit out multiple copies of our press release to you and did not send out a follow-up news coverage of the issue. I apologize to my readers of AgBioView for this.
We believe there may be quite a simple explanation for what occurred: the AgBioWorld website caught fire.
The answer's clear from the press releases that AgBioWorld spat out to the media.
Here's what Prakash & co. claimed.
Academic and Science Community Applauds WTO GMO Ruling
Contact: Dr. CS Prakash of the AgBioWorld Foundation, 334-444-7884; Prakash(at)tuskegee.edu
WASHINGTON, Feb. 7-- Independent academics and scientists from around the globe applaud the long-awaited World Trade Organization ruling today which directs the European Union to end its defacto moratorium on biotechnology-improved crops.
WTO-GMO Ruling: Independent Academic Experts Available
TUSKEGEE INSTITUTE, AL -- (MARKET WIRE) -- 02/07/2006 -- The AgBioWorld Foundation, a non-profit coalition of global academics committed to sharing science-based information on agricultural biotechnology issues, has compiled a list of academic experts available to provide analysis and commentary regarding the World Trade Organization dispute, "EC - Measures Affecting the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products" (WT/DS291).
On the AgBioWorld list of "Independent Academic Experts" available to advise the world's media were such luminaries as "Gregory Conko, Senior Fellow, Competitive Enterprise Institute". The CEI is a Washington based pro-corporate pressure group that takes money from Monsanto, Dow, Exxon, Big Tobacco etc. Unsurprisingly, it dismisses global warming, opposes restrictions on smoking and promotes GMOs.
As a leading light of the CEI, Conko is hardly independent and nor, for that matter, is he an academic. Yet, as one of the AgBioWorld press releases admits somewhere near the bottom, it was Conko who co-founded "the AgBioWorld community" of "global academics".
CS Prakash himself is a previous winner of GM Watch's PANTS ON FIRE award. His smoking undergarments were acknowledged not just because of all the bogus claims he's made about the supposed successes of GM crops but also because he promoted AgBioWorld as an independent academic effort when it's been heavily dependent on Monsanto's PR firm, Bivings.
It was Bivings who designed AgBioWorld's website and ran its archive off their server, and it was Bivings who with Monsanto coordinated poison pen attacks on Monsanto's critics that were launched, and given prominence, courtesy of AgBioView.
These AgBioView attacks, made under the aliases "Mary Murphy" and "Andura Smetacek", drew much admiration from Prakash and his supporters. For instance, another of those listed amongst AgBioWorld's "Independent Academic Experts" ready to analyse the WTO dispute was someone who responded to Monsanto's PR attacks with particular appreciation:
...In sum, I have one word for your comments - MAGNIFICENT! Keep on posting your comments.
(From: Tom DeGregori [email protected], Subject: Re: AGBIOVIEW: Stossel, Archive: Message #689, Date: August 8, 2000)
In an article - appropriately entitled "Genetically Modified Nonsense", DeGregori even claimed that opposition to GMOs in Europe was the result of much of the European population having been "brainwashed". And according to the blurb for his book, "Bountiful Harvest", "DeGregori argues that innovations such as bioengineered foods have increased life expectancy, crop yields and generally improved human well-being"!!!
Nor is DeGregori the only person on CS Prakash's list of "Independent Academic Experts" displaying a questionable contact with reality. Take, for instance, Dr. Henry I. Miller who co-authored a book on GM with Prakash's CEI sidekick Greg Conko. In "The Frankenfood Myth" Miller and Conko claim that GMOs have suffered their global set back due to their over-regulation by the United States. They claim this despite the fact that the US operates an entirely voluntary system of GM approvals - a system that Miller freely admits was designed and dictated by the biotech industry itself. Yet Miller and Conko argue that the industry's fatal error was to agree to any regulatory controls on GMOs at all!
Miller links to a veritable network of right-wing lobby groups. He operates primarily out of the Hoover Institution but is also an 'adjunct scholar' at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a director of the American Council on Science and Health and a director of Consumer Alert. He was also part of the pro-GM/anti-organic 'No More Scares' group with the journalist Michael Fumento, who was recently sacked by Scripps Howard News Service for failing to disclose receiving $60,000 from Monsanto.
Another "Independent Academic Expert" on the Prakash list with grave problems with reality is Calestous Juma of Harvard. Juma, who was once memorably described by a well-known journalist as "the most up himself
Go to a Print friendly Page
Email this Article to a Friend
Back to the Archive